ST. LOUIS — The St. Louis City Council voted Sept. 1 to extend its trash and recycling contract with Granger Waste Services by 24 months, to April 30, 2029, contingent on the Alma City Commission doing the same. Under Granger’s offer, the monthly charge for a household’s trash and recycling rises from $13.56 now to $14.24 on May 1, 2027, and to $14.95 a year later. The contract in the council’s Sept. 1 packet also contains the fuel clause behind the diesel surcharge the council approved Oct. 20, and its terms are steeper than what Granger asked for.
The record at a glance
- The vote: Council Member Robin Hart moved and Mayor Pro Tem William Leonard supported; “All ayes carried the motion,” with all five members present (Sept. 1 minutes, p. 2).
- The term: the 2022 contract runs May 1, 2022 through April 30, 2027, with options to extend 12 or 24 months; the council chose 24.
- The price: $13.56 a month now ($12.16 trash, $1.40 recycling); $14.24 from May 1, 2027 ($12.77 + $1.47); $14.95 from May 1, 2028 ($13.41 + $1.54). Each step is a 5% increase.
- The fuel clause: after diesel stays above $4.00 a gallon for three consecutive months, one cent per household for each 4 cents above $4.00, subject to council approval.
What the council approved
City Manager Kurt Giles’s Aug. 28 memo (PDF pp. 135–136) says the city’s 2022 bid and contract with Granger “had provisions for a 12-month or 24-month optional extension if both parties wished to extend the contract and could establish agreeable terms.” Alma and St. Louis took bids jointly through the Gratiot Area Solid Waste Authority, and the signed 2022 agreement is on the authority’s form: it names the City of Alma as owner in its opening line and is signed for the authority by its chairperson, Kurt Giles, and for Granger (PDF p. 139). It runs May 1, 2022, through April 30, 2027, with options to extend 12 or 24 more months if both sides agree.
The memo listed three choices: a 12-month extension at 5% over the current year’s price, a 24-month extension with a second 5% increase on May 1, 2028, or declining both and taking bids for a new contract “in the first 1/4 of 2027.” It says management in both Alma and St. Louis recommended the 24-month offer “to provide continuing services through April 30, 2029,” based on cost comparisons and “the level of service both communities have received over the past 4-1/2 years.”
The motion approved the 24-month extension “contingent on the Alma City Commission’s approval of the contract extension” (Sept. 1 minutes, p. 2). The memo says the item was scheduled to go to Alma’s commission on Sept. 8. The agenda statement lists the cost as budgeted, with no budget amendment needed (PDF p. 134).
What households pay
Granger’s 2022 bid (PDF p. 146) set the same household prices for Alma and St. Louis: $11.15 a month for trash and every-other-week recycling in the first contract year, rising each year to $13.56 in year five, the year that began May 1, 2026. Granger’s extension sheet for St. Louis (PDF p. 163) lists the household rate at $13.56 now and $14.24 in the first extension year. It also lists the city’s own commercial containers, at its electric department, public works, wastewater plant, City Hall, library and housing sites, at $1,435.51 a month now and $1,507.29 in that year.
Giles’s memo compares the offer with other places. Holland took bids this year for a five-year contract, and Republic Services won at $16.46 a month in year one with a 4% yearly increase. Coldwater’s winning proposal was $16.95 a month in year one, including large-item pickup, with 5% increases. The memo gives 2024 monthly equivalents for trash only of $16.67 in Jasper Township, $15.54 in Pine River Township and $18.75 in Porter Township (PDF p. 136).
The fuel clause
Our Nov. 4 report said Granger’s Oct. 8 letter to St. Louis cited a contract provision allowing a surcharge when diesel stays above $4.00 a gallon for three straight months, and that Granger chose $5.00 instead. We said then that the contracts were not in the packets we had read. The Sept. 1 packet includes the St. Louis and Alma contract, and its Attachment 1, “Alternative Fuel Adjustment Factor” (PDF p. 148), reads in part:
- “Any rate change shall be subject to approval by the City Council. The Contractor may not assess any rates or fees not so approved.”
- “In the event that the cost of diesel exceeds $4.00 per gallon continuously for three (3) consecutive months, Contractor reserves the right to charge the Resident a fuel surcharge per household for each month the price is above $4.00 per gallon. Pricing shall increase $0.01 for each $0.04 increase in diesel fuel above the $4.00 per gallon.”
- The attachment’s example: at $4.40 a gallon, “the fuel surcharge would be $0.10 per household, per month.” Prices are taken from the U.S. Department of Energy’s Midwest index.
The surcharge Granger asked for, and the council approved Oct. 20, is one cent for each 5 cents above $5.00, which Granger’s letter put at 27 cents a household at September’s price of $6.351 a gallon. Under the contract’s formula, the same price is $2.351 above $4.00, which would allow about 58 cents.
What we do not know yet
- Whether Alma’s commission approved the extension on Sept. 8, which the St. Louis vote depends on. Alma’s website has not been readable by our automated checks.
- Whether St. Louis will add the fuel surcharge to residents’ bills or pay it from the solid waste fund; the contract’s wording refers to charging “the Resident.”
- The October diesel price and the first month’s surcharge.
- Whether the extension changes any other contract term; the packet includes Granger’s pricing but not a signed extension.
Corrections and responses are welcome.